Madras High Court Rules on Governor’s Remission Powers
On 2 April 2026, a three-judge full bench of the Madras High Court ruled that the Governor must act on the Council of Ministers’ advice when exercising powers under Article 161 of the Constitution concerning remission and premature release of convicts.
Article 161 and Cabinet advice
The bench held that the Governor cannot independently reject Cabinet decisions on these matters. It said the Governor is a formal head who must act according to the Council of Ministers’ advice. Justices A.D. Jagadish Chandira, G.K. Ilanthiraiyan and Sunder Mohan delivered the ruling.
Case background
The ruling arose from a challenge to the Governor’s rejection of the Tamil Nadu Cabinet’s recommendation to release John David, a life convict in the Navarasu murder case. The case was referred to a larger bench in September 2025 after conflicting decisions by earlier High Court Division Benches. The full bench cited Supreme Court rulings in Shamsher Singh v State of Punjab (1974), Maru Ramu (1980) and A.G. Perarivalan (2022).
Important Facts for Exams
- Delay in mercy decisions: In death-sentence cases, excessive delay in carrying out the sentence has been treated as a mitigating factor in seeking commutation.
- Remission versus commutation: Remission shortens the period of a sentence without changing its character; commutation substitutes a less severe form of punishment.
- Fourteen-year minimum for certain life sentences: Under BNSS section 475, some life prisoners cannot be released until they have served at least fourteen years in prison.
- State executive-power boundary: Article 161 applies to offences connected with matters within the State’s executive-power sphere; it is not an unrestricted power over every offence.