Supreme Court Sets Aside Rajasthan Reserve-List Appointment Orders
On January 15, 2026, the Supreme Court of India set aside Rajasthan High Court orders directing appointments from reserve lists in the Junior Legal Officer (JLO) 2013 and Assistant Statistical Officer (ASO) 2020 recruitment cases.
Reserve-list appointments
A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih held that inclusion on a reserve or waiting list does not create an automatic or vested right to appointment. Under the relevant Rajasthan service rules, reserve lists remain valid for six months from the date the original select list is forwarded. Appointments cannot be ordered after that period or without a formal requisition from the appointing authority.
RPSC’s right to appeal
The Court held that the Rajasthan Public Service Commission, as a constitutional body, had legal standing to appeal the High Court’s directions even without an appeal by the State Government. The ruling overturned decisions by both single-judge and division benches of the Rajasthan High Court that had favoured candidates seeking appointments from the lists.
Important Facts for Exams
- Constitutional basis: The Rajasthan Public Service Commission is constituted under Article 315 of the Constitution, providing its constitutional basis as a state public service commission.
- Service-matter advice: Alongside recruitment, the Rajasthan Public Service Commission advises the state government on service rules, promotions and disciplinary cases.
- State commission tenure: Under Article 316, the Governor appoints a State Public Service Commission’s chairperson and members; their tenure ends after six years or at age 62, whichever comes first.
- Commission-member removal: Article 317 vests removal of a State Public Service Commission chairperson or member in the President; alleged misbehaviour requires an inquiry by the Supreme Court.