Karnataka High Court Strikes Down Pan-Masala Cess
On July 13, 2026, a single-judge bench of the Karnataka High Court, presided over by Justice M. Nagaprasanna, invalidated a health and national security cess on pan masala calculated from packing machines’ potential output rather than actual production.
Basis of the ruling
The court held that the assessment method was arbitrary and violated Article 14 of the Constitution. It said the framework treated machines of different capacities alike, resulting in arbitrary and discriminatory treatment. The challenged measures were the Health Security and National Security Cess Act, 2025, and the Health Security and National Security Cess Rules, 2026.
Parliament’s power to impose a cess
The court upheld Parliament’s legislative competence to impose a cess under its residuary powers. It clarified that the Centre could legislate afresh to impose the cess, provided any new law complied with the judgment’s observations.
Important Facts for Exams
- Classification test: Article 14 permits reasonable classification only where an intelligible difference separates the groups and the distinction has a rational connection to the law’s objective.
- Residuary legislative field: Article 248, read with Union List Entry 97, gives Parliament exclusive authority over subjects absent from the State and Concurrent Lists, including unenumerated taxes.