Madhya Pradesh High Court rules registered adoption deed not required for compassionate appointment
The Madhya Pradesh High Court ruled on April 6, 2026, that a registered adoption deed is not mandatory to establish a legally valid adoption for compassionate appointment. It set aside the rejection of Mohit Goud’s application and directed authorities to reconsider it within 60 days.
Adoption and compassionate appointment rules
In Mohit Goud v. The State of Madhya Pradesh and Others, Justice Jai Kumar Pillai held that the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, does not make registration of an adoption deed a precondition for a valid adoption. Clause 2.5 of the state’s compassionate appointment policy recognises adopted children as eligible dependents when the adoption was legally valid and took place during the employee’s lifetime. Authorities cannot impose conditions beyond those set by statute or existing policy.
Background to the case
Goud’s adoption took place in 2010, and an adoption deed was notarised in 2020. His adoptive father, a Superior Field Worker in the Malaria Department, died during the COVID-19 pandemic in April 2021. Authorities rejected Goud’s application, arguing that the deed was registered only after his father’s death and that no succession certificate had been produced.
Important Facts for Exams
- Spousal consent: A Hindu man generally needs his wife’s consent to adopt; an unmarried man may adopt if he is not a minor.
- Adoptee eligibility: The adoptee generally must be unmarried and under 15, though applicable custom or usage can permit marriage or an older child.
- Same-sex adoption restriction: Under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, a Hindu cannot adopt a son if a specified living male descendant already exists; a parallel restriction applies to adopting a daughter.
- Giving-and-taking requirement: A valid adoption requires actual giving and taking with intent to transfer the child from the birth family to the adoptive family; a datta homam is unnecessary.