Karnataka High Court Rules Against GST on Minimum-Balance Penalties
On 1 June 2026, the Karnataka High Court, in an order delivered by Justice S.R. Krishna Kumar, ruled that Goods and Services Tax (GST) cannot be levied on bank penalties for failing to maintain a minimum average balance.
Court's reasoning and notices
The court quashed show-cause notices issued to Canara Bank, Bank of Baroda and Karnataka Bank. It held that maintaining a minimum average balance is a contractual obligation, not consideration for a taxable service. The penalty is punitive, not profit or payment for a service, and banks do not charge a separate service fee for maintaining the required balance. The court also held that maintaining a minimum average balance is not a banking service under the Finance Act, 1994, and that service tax or GST cannot be imposed on the penalties.
GST authorities' position
GST authorities had argued that the penalties were taxable because banks gained liquidity and other financial benefits from customers' minimum balances.