High Court Holds BSNL Liable in SIM-Swap Fraud
The Karnataka High Court held Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) liable for losses caused by a SIM-swap fraud involving Sri Basaveshwara Pattana Sahakara Bank Niyamitha, a cooperative bank based in Shiralkoppa, Shivamogga district. Justice Suraj Govindaraj delivered the judgment on June 1, 2026.
How the fraud occurred
Seven unauthorised RTGS and NEFT transfers totalling ₹87.70 lakh were made from the bank’s Canara Bank account on February 6 and 7, 2019. The fraud was enabled by the unauthorised issue of a duplicate BSNL SIM card for the bank’s registered mobile number, used for internet banking and one-time password (OTP) authentication.
Compensation ordered
The court directed BSNL to pay ₹50,50,762 for the bank’s net financial loss, plus ₹5 lakh for consequential damages. It also ordered 9% annual interest on the net-loss amount from February 7, 2019, until payment, to be made within three months. The court rejected BSNL’s argument against vicarious liability and emphasised the telecom provider’s duty of care when issuing SIM cards.
Important Facts for Exams
- Number porting: A SIM-swap attack exploits a provider’s ability to transfer a phone number to a device using a different SIM, redirecting the victim’s mobile service.
- RTGS–NEFT settlement distinction: RTGS settles each payment individually in real time, whereas NEFT clears transactions in half-hourly batches; both systems operate around the clock.
- Transfer amount limits: The RBI sets a ₹2 lakh minimum for RTGS but no upper ceiling; it imposes no minimum or maximum amount for NEFT transactions.
- Cooperative-bank oversight: India’s cooperative banks face RBI oversight for banking regulation, while cooperative registrars retain responsibility for incorporation and cooperative-law administration.