Andhra Pradesh High Court Full Bench differs on commercial-court notification; Justice Tilhari urges senior-level courts be made functional
On 18 May 2026, a three-judge Andhra Pradesh High Court Full Bench answered a reference in civil revision petitions concerning the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, as amended in 2018. The majority and Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari, in a separate opinion, differed on the need for a State notification.
Majority on the Threshold
The majority held that the amended specified-value threshold of at least ₹3 lakh took effect on 3 May 2018 without a separate government notification. It distinguished this threshold from the pecuniary jurisdiction of an individual commercial court. The existing commercial courts at Visakhapatnam and Vijayawada should receive qualifying disputes above ₹3 lakh through fresh proceedings. A notification under Section 3(1A) would be relevant if commercial courts below District Judge level were established.
Justice Tilhari’s Separate Opinion
Justice Tilhari said a State notification under Section 3(1A) was necessary for disputes valued from ₹3 lakh to below ₹1 crore to be heard in the commercial courts. He also urged implementation of the 2023 order converting 13 Fast Track Courts into Senior Civil Judge-level commercial courts and called for them to be made functional. These views were not a unanimous direction of the Full Bench.
Important Facts for Exams
- Pre-institution mediation: Section 12A requires pre-institution mediation for commercial suits not seeking urgent interim relief; the process is ordinarily limited to three months, extendable by two.
- Specified-value calculation: For a debt or damages claim, specified value includes interest calculated up to the date the suit is filed.
- Case management procedure: Order XV-A of the Code of Civil Procedure provides case-management hearings in commercial disputes to set procedural timetables and facilitate trial.
- Appeal deadline: Section 13 generally provides a 60-day limit for appeals against appealable Commercial Court decisions to the designated Commercial Appellate Court or Division.