Uttarakhand High Court Bars Tax on Hydropower Generation

Uttarakhand High Court Bars Tax on Hydropower Generation

The Uttarakhand High Court ruled on April 27, 2026, that the state government cannot tax electricity generated by hydropower projects. Justice Alok Kumar Verma delivered the judgment while sitting as a single judge.

Challenge to the state law

The ruling concerned special appeals challenging the constitutional validity of the Uttarakhand Water Tax on Electricity Generation Act, 2012. The Act imposed a water tax of 2 to 10 paise per unit, depending on project capacity. The case, T.H.D.C. India Ltd vs State of Uttarakhand & Others, came before the court after a Division Bench delivered a split verdict in October 2023.

Court’s reasoning

Applying the pith and substance doctrine, the court found that the levy was, in its real character, a tax on electricity generation rather than merely on the drawing or use of water. It held that the state legislature lacked competence to impose such a tax, which falls within the Union government’s domain.

Important Facts for Exams

  • Indian application: The pith and substance doctrine is used in India to add flexibility to the otherwise rigid distribution of legislative powers.
  • Electricity-taxing power: Entry 53 of the State List authorises taxes on electricity consumption or sale, but does not expressly confer a general power to tax electricity generation.
  • Concurrent legislative subject: Electricity is a Concurrent List subject under Entry 38, so both Parliament and State legislatures may legislate, with Article 254 governing inconsistent laws.
  • Water-power jurisdiction: State List Entry 17 covers water and water power, subject to Union List Entry 56, which allows Union control of inter-State rivers when Parliament declares it expedient in public interest.
Category: Uttarakhand
Originally written on April 27, 2026 and last modified on November 19, 2026.
Tags: , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *