Possessory Remedies

Possessory remedies refer to the legal measures available to protect and restore possession, regardless of ownership. They are founded on the principle that possession itself is a protected legal interest, deserving of recognition and defence even against the true owner in certain circumstances. The law values possession because it maintains social order, prevents conflicts, and ensures stability in property relations.
These remedies aim to safeguard individuals from unlawful interference, dispossession, or disturbance of possession, providing redress through civil or criminal proceedings.
Meaning and Purpose of Possessory Remedies
Possessory remedies are legal protections granted to a person in possession—lawful or unlawful—against disturbance or wrongful dispossession by others. The purpose of such remedies is not to determine ownership but to preserve peaceful possession until ownership is legally established.
The underlying principle is expressed in the legal maxim:“Possession is protected even against the true owner, if the true owner attempts to recover property by force or without due process of law.”
Thus, the law discourages self-help and insists that possession can only be disturbed through legal procedure.
The primary objectives of possessory remedies are:
- To maintain public order by preventing unlawful dispossession.
- To protect possession as an independent right.
- To discourage violent or forceful recovery of property.
- To ensure that disputes are resolved through judicial mechanisms rather than private force.
Legal Basis of Possessory Remedies
Possessory remedies arise from both common law principles and statutory provisions. At common law, possession was treated as a legally protected interest, even when the possessor was not the owner. Modern legal systems continue this principle, recognising that possession—especially long, continuous, or lawful possession—creates certain enforceable rights.
In India and other common law jurisdictions, possessory remedies are recognised under:
- The Law of Torts, which provides actions for trespass, nuisance, or wrongful interference with possession.
- The Specific Relief Act, 1963, particularly Section 6, which protects possession irrespective of ownership.
- The Criminal Procedure Code and Penal Code, which penalise criminal trespass, mischief, and unlawful dispossession.
Possessory Remedies under Civil Law
Civil possessory remedies are intended to restore possession or prevent interference. They are independent of ownership and are available to any person unlawfully deprived of possession. The main civil remedies include:
1. Action for Recovery of Possession
A person unlawfully dispossessed of immovable or movable property can file a civil suit for possession. The purpose of this remedy is to restore the status quo ante (the position before dispossession).
Under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963:
- No person shall be dispossessed of immovable property except in accordance with law.
- A person in possession may recover the property even from the true owner if the latter has used force or illegal means to dispossess.
- The suit must be brought within six months of dispossession.
- No suit can be filed against the State under this section.
This section embodies the principle that lawful possession must be protected against unlawful interference, and even the owner must resort to legal procedure to reclaim property.
2. Action for Trespass
Trespass is a direct and unlawful interference with another’s possession of land, goods, or chattels. The possessor may sue for damages or injunction against the wrongdoer.
Types of trespass:
- Trespass to land: Unauthorised entry upon another’s property.
- Trespass to goods: Unlawful interference with another’s movable possessions.
- Trespass to person: Though not strictly a possessory issue, it may relate to interference with physical control over personal property.
The possessor’s right to sue does not depend on ownership but on actual possession. Even a tenant, bailee, or finder of goods has a right of action against trespassers.
3. Action for Nuisance
Nuisance involves indirect interference with the enjoyment of possession, such as through noise, pollution, smoke, or obstruction. A possessor may claim damages or seek an injunction to prevent continued interference.
While trespass affects possession directly, nuisance affects the use and enjoyment of possession. The remedy is particularly relevant to possessors of land and immovable property.
4. Injunctions
An injunction is a court order restraining a person from interfering with possession. It may be:
- Prohibitory, preventing a threatened or continuing act of dispossession.
- Mandatory, compelling restoration of possession or removal of unlawful structures.
Injunctions are often sought alongside other remedies, providing preventive protection before or during the pendency of a possessory dispute.
5. Possession under Adverse Possession
While not strictly a remedy, the doctrine of adverse possession operates as a form of protection to long, uninterrupted possession. If the true owner fails to assert ownership within the statutory limitation period, the possessor acquires ownership by operation of law.
This doctrine reflects the policy that possession, when peaceful and open, should eventually ripen into ownership to promote certainty and discourage neglect.
Possessory Remedies under Criminal Law
Criminal law also provides safeguards to prevent unlawful interference with possession, particularly of immovable property. These remedies are aimed at maintaining public peace and order.
-
Criminal Trespass (Sections 441–447, Indian Penal Code):
- Entry into or occupation of another’s property with intent to annoy, intimidate, or insult the lawful possessor constitutes an offence.
- Punishment includes imprisonment or fine, ensuring deterrence against forcible entry or occupation.
-
Mischief (Sections 425–440, Indian Penal Code):
- Acts causing wrongful loss or damage to property interfere with possession and attract criminal liability.
-
Unlawful Dispossession (Section 145, Criminal Procedure Code):
- Magistrates may intervene to prevent breaches of peace relating to possession of land or water.
- The court determines who was in possession at the time of dispute and may restore possession accordingly, leaving ownership questions for civil courts.
These provisions demonstrate the state’s commitment to maintaining peaceful possession and preventing violent self-help.
Possessory Remedies for Movable Property
In the case of movable property, possessory remedies include:
- Action for Detinue: Recovery of a specific chattel wrongfully detained.
- Action for Conversion: Damages for wrongful appropriation or interference with goods.
- Replevin: Common law remedy to recover unlawfully taken goods.
These remedies protect not only owners but also lawful possessors such as bailees, finders, or pledgees.
Principles Underlying Possessory Remedies
The protection of possession rests on several key legal principles:
- Maintenance of peace: Preventing individuals from taking the law into their own hands.
- Presumption of ownership: Possession serves as prima facie evidence of ownership.
- Independence from ownership: Possession is protected even against the owner if possession is disturbed unlawfully.
- Promotion of social order: Stability in property relations discourages conflict and economic uncertainty.