Calcutta High Court restrains West Bengal from acting under alleged surplus-teacher SOP
On 15 September 2026, in Soma Sardar v. State of West Bengal, the Calcutta High Court directed the State respondents not to take steps under an alleged Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) used to collect teacher data and facilitate school selection for transfers.
Challenge to the alleged SOP
The petitioner, an assistant teacher in English (Pass) at a high school since 2013, challenged her inclusion in a surplus-teacher list and argued that the SOP lacked a supporting legal provision. The Court noted that the copy before it had no date or signature and that no legal provision supporting its use had been placed before the Court.
Interim directions
The interim restraint is to remain in force until 18 December 2026 or until further orders, whichever comes first. The respondents were also directed to disclose the legal basis and mechanism for identifying teachers as surplus.
Important Facts for Exams
- Executive instructions and service rules: In Sant Ram Sharma v State of Rajasthan (1967), the Supreme Court held executive instructions may fill gaps where service rules are silent but cannot amend or supersede statutory rules.