Allahabad High Court Sets Test for Contract Workers’ Equal-Pay Claims
The Allahabad High Court on 15 October 2026 set aside an order granting 265 contract workers at Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (BHEL), Jhansi, pay and allowances equal to those of regular unskilled employees.
Court sets test for equal-pay claims
Justice Saurabh Shyam Shamshery ruled that contract workers seeking equal pay must prove their work is equivalent in nature, quality and responsibility to that of regular employees. Matching job titles alone is insufficient. BHEL management had challenged the Labour Commissioner, Uttar Pradesh’s order, dated 5 January 2005.
Case sent for reconsideration
The High Court directed the Labour Commissioner to reconsider the case within six months of receiving the certified judgment, after assessing the relevant facts and evidence. It referred to the Supreme Court’s ruling in State of Punjab v. Jagjit Singh, which places the burden of proving parity in duties and responsibilities on the claimant.
Important Facts for Exams
- Constitutional route: In India, equal pay for equal work is not expressly a constitutional right; it has been read into Articles 14, 15 and 16.
- Actual duties: Indian courts assess whether work is similar by examining duties actually performed, rather than duties an employee might potentially perform.
- Jagjit Singh pay-scale limit: In State of Punjab v Jagjit Singh (2016), temporary employees performing the same duties as regular staff were entitled to the regular pay scale’s minimum, without increments.