Supreme Court Mandates Three Years of Legal Practice for Judicial Service Aspirants
The Supreme Court has reinstated a pivotal eligibility criterion for aspirants of the judicial services examination. The candidates must possess a minimum of three years of legal practice to qualify for entry-level judicial positions, such as Civil Judge (Junior Division) posts.
Background and Rationale
This decision overturns the 2002 ruling that allowed fresh law graduates to directly enter the judiciary without prior courtroom experience. The court observed that this earlier approach led to challenges in judicial efficacy, as judges without practical experience often lacked the necessary skills to handle complex legal matters effectively.
Implementation Details
The three-year practice requirement will be calculated from the date of a candidate’s provisional enrollment as an advocate, not from the date of passing the All India Bar Examination (AIBE). To validate this experience, candidates must obtain a certificate from an advocate with at least 10 years of standing at the Bar, endorsed by a judicial officer of the respective court. Additionally, experience gained as a law clerk to judges will be recognized as valid legal practice for this purpose.
Scope and Applicability
The Supreme Court clarified that this requirement applies prospectively and will not affect ongoing recruitment processes already initiated by High Courts. All State Governments and High Courts are directed to amend their respective service rules to incorporate this eligibility criterion for future recruitments .
Implications for Aspirants
This ruling significantly alters the pathway for law graduates aspiring to join the judiciary. It emphasizes the importance of practical legal experience, ensuring that future judges are better equipped to handle the responsibilities of the role. While this may extend the timeline for entering judicial service, it aims to enhance the overall quality and effectiveness of the judiciary.
For law graduates, this means engaging in active legal practice or clerkships to meet the new eligibility criteria, thereby gaining valuable experience that will serve them in their future judicial roles.
| Related | |
|---|---|
