NFL Bans Hip-Drop Tackle in 2024

The National Football League (NFL) has prohibited the use of the hip-drop tackle starting from the 2024 season. The decision was made during the annual league meeting in Orlando, Florida, on Monday, March 25, 2024, where the competition committee unanimously voted in favor of the change. The hip-drop tackle is a controversial technique resulting in multiple player injuries over the years, prompting the NFL to take action to ensure player safety.

Understanding Hip-Drop Tackle

The hip-drop tackle is a technique where a defender wraps the ball carrier with both arms or holds them with both hands, then unweights himself by swiveling and dropping his hips and/or lower body, landing on and trapping the runner’s leg(s) at or below the knee. This move causes significant injuries to players, particularly to their legs and knees, as the full weight of the defender is concentrated on a small area of the ball carrier’s body.

Reason for the Ban

The NFL is pushing for a rule change regarding the hip-drop tackle due to its association with player injuries. Commissioner Roger Goodell has been a strong advocate for player safety, and the ban on the hip-drop tackle is another step towards reducing the risk of injury on the field. The NFL Players Association (NFLPA) has also raised concerns about the technique, citing the high risk of injury it poses to players.

Injury Examples

Several high-profile injuries have been caused by the hip-drop tackle in recent years. One notable example is the tackle by former San Francisco 49ers safety Jimmie Ward on Dallas Cowboys running back Tony Pollard during the 2022 postseason, which resulted in a severe leg injury for Pollard. Another instance occurred in 2023 when Baltimore Ravens tight end Mark Andrews was injured by a hip-drop tackle against the Cincinnati Bengals.

Data and Analysis

The NFL conducts extensive research on the hip-drop tackle to support the decision to ban the technique. Out of 20,000 tackles examined by the NFL since 2022, 105 have been identified as hip-drop tackles. The data shows that the hip-drop tackle increases the risk of injury by 25 times compared to the average tackle rate. This alarming statistic highlights the need for the NFL to take action to protect players from unnecessary harm.

Implementation and Penalties

Starting from the 2024 season, any hip-drop tackle that occurs during play will result in a 15-yard penalty, possible fines, and a player warning. The NFL emphasizes that the rule change will be strictly enforced to ensure compliance and to create a safer playing environment for all players.

Criticism and Concerns

Despite the NFL’s commitment to player safety, the rule change faces criticism from some players, coaches, and fans who argue that it may lead to confusion and inconsistency in officiating. The NFLPA objects to the ban, stating that the rule change may cause confusion for players, coaches, officials, and fans. They have called on the NFL to reconsider implementing the rule and to provide more clarity on how it will be enforced.

International Comparison

The hip-drop tackle ban is not unique to the NFL. In fact, other professional football leagues around the world, such as the Australian Football League (AFL) and the Rugby Football Union (RFU) in England, have already implemented similar rules to protect players from dangerous tackles. These leagues have seen a reduction in the number of injuries related to hip-drop tackles since implementing the ban, providing a positive example for the NFL to follow.

The NFL’s decision to ban the hip-drop tackle starting from the 2024 season is a significant step towards improving player safety and reducing the risk of serious injuries on the field. While the rule change may face some criticism and challenges in its implementation, the NFL remains committed to prioritizing the health and well-being of its players.



Leave a Reply