Madhya Pradesh High Court says divorced daughter’s family-pension claim must be considered subject to dependency
On 12 May 2026, the Madhya Pradesh High Court at Jabalpur held that excluding a divorced daughter from the relevant family definition while including married daughters violated Article 14. The ruling came in Jyoti Shrivastava v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Others.
Court directs reconsideration
Justice Vishal Dhagat quashed the 16 December 2021 rejection of Shrivastava’s family-pension claim and directed the authorities to reconsider it. The claim must be allowed only if she is found dependent on her deceased father and without an independent source of income. The competent authority must decide within 90 days of receiving a fresh representation with evidence.
Important Facts for Exams
- Reasonable classification: Article 14 allows reasonable classification, requiring an intelligible basis for grouping and a rational link between that grouping and the law’s objective.
- Non-arbitrariness: Article 14 also requires classifications to be non-arbitrary; the Supreme Court has described equality and arbitrariness as opposing principles.
- Article 14 coverage: Article 14 protects any person within India’s territory, including non-citizens; several other fundamental rights, such as Article 15, are expressly limited to citizens.
- High Court writ jurisdiction: High Courts may issue writs to enforce fundamental rights and for other purposes; this jurisdiction is broader than Article 32’s rights-enforcement remit.
Category: Madhya Pradesh
Originally written on
May 12, 2026
and last modified on
November 20, 2026.
Tags: Article 14, family pension, Justice Vishal Dhagat, Jyoti Shrivastava, Madhya Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh High Court